Latest

FirstAmerica First

I Said We Would Keep Congress. I Was Wrong. Here Is What Comes Next.

Democrats won the House and the Senate. I called it wrong. Here is what happened, what it means for factories, life and faith, and what we do now.

Engraved-style scene in cream on deep navy of a small white church and a sawtooth-roof factory side by side at dawn, with a low sun rising behind rolling hills and a small American flag on a pole, inside a thin double-rule border.

On October 16, I published a post called “Forget the Doom: Republicans Are Keeping the House and Senate.” I said we would win. I told you to get ready to celebrate on November 3.

I was wrong. Democrats won the House and the Senate. This blog has one rule: no source, no claim. That rule has to cover my own predictions too. So here is what happened, where I went wrong, and what we do now.

What happened

Before the election, Republicans held the Senate 53 to 47, per the AP (opens in a new tab). The AP reports (opens in a new tab) that Democrats took back the Senate “in a flurry of victories late Tuesday.” They reached a House majority early Wednesday.

In the Senate, Democrats flipped nine Republican seats. The AP says (opens in a new tab) that is their biggest midterm gain in nearly 70 years. Alaska was the last Senate race to be called. The AP (opens in a new tab) says it gave Democrats a 56 to 44 majority.

The House moved just as far. Going in, 219 members caucused with Republicans, one more than a bare majority. As of the morning of November 19, the AP results page (opens in a new tab) shows 257 seats for Democrats and 172 for Republicans. Six races are still not called.

The losses came in places we counted as safe. The AP (opens in a new tab) lists Democratic Senate wins in Texas and South Carolina. In Kansas, voters elected their first Democratic senator since 1932.

Why? The AP (opens in a new tab) names voters’ “deep frustrations over high prices” first. The AP Voter Poll (opens in a new tab) found that young voters led a sharp shift toward Democrats. I take both facts seriously. Prices are the kitchen table. Young people are the future of this movement. We have to earn both.

Where I went wrong

I trusted the map and the record. I wrote, “History is just what happened when people didn’t show up to change it.” That was a good line and a bad forecast. Hope is a duty. It is not a poll. Next time I will show you the evidence on both sides before I tell you what I hope.

What it means for factories

The new Congress starts at noon on January 3, under the 20th Amendment (opens in a new tab). A change of majority does not repeal existing law. The IRS (opens in a new tab) confirms that the One, Big, Beautiful Bill made the 100% first-year depreciation deduction permanent. Congress would have to pass a new law to repeal that deduction. The President could veto it. Under the Constitution (opens in a new tab), Congress then needs two thirds in each chamber to override the veto. Neither party can assume it has those votes.

Under current Senate rules (opens in a new tab), ending debate on most legislation takes 60 votes. The 56-seat Democratic bloc falls short. I will not promise that every policy is safe. I want both parties to back reliable power, skilled workers and factories that make things here.

What it means for life

Here the risk is real, and I will not soften it. The Hyde Amendment restricts abortion funding in covered federal health programs, with exceptions. Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute (opens in a new tab) explains that it “is not a permanent law; it must be renewed annually.” So every year, that protection has to be won again in a spending bill. With Democrats running both chambers, that fight gets harder.

For Catholics, this is not one issue on a long list. The Catechism (opens in a new tab) says, “Human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception.” The U.S. bishops (opens in a new tab) say it plainly: “The threat of abortion remains our pre-eminent priority.” Every other right depends on that one. I wrote about it here. I want the President and pro-life senators to defend that right. Hold them to it, and pray for them.

What it means for family and faith

No Congress raises a child. No Speaker fills a pew. The most important work in this country happens at kitchen tables, in parishes and in workshops. That work did not stop on November 3. I want the next Congress to make family life easier, not to take over its work. I will judge bills by what they do for parents, the freedom to practice our faith and honest work.

What we do now

In October, I wrote that despair is a choice. It was true before the vote. It is true after it. So here is the homework:

  • Call your new member of Congress, even if you voted against them. Ask them to keep Hyde protections in the health spending bill.
  • Look hard at the cost of living in your town. Write about it. Argue about it. Our side has to win that question again.
  • Get involved locally. School boards, parish councils and town meetings need steady work between elections.
  • Pray for the country, for the people who won, and for the people who lost.

In the 2019 State of the Union (opens in a new tab), the President said, “Victory is not winning for our party. Victory is winning for our country.” We lost this round for our party. The work of winning for our country goes on. I will be here for it, and I will be more honest about the odds next time.

Sources